Vehicle driver safety performance based on relativity

ABSTRACT

Systems, methods, and techniques for determining optimal safe driving behaviors and optimal safety thresholds of the various parameters for particular routes are disclosed. Historical driver data for a plurality of drivers operating vehicles over various routes during different contextual situations and/or different combinations of conditions along the routes is analyzed to determine respective, relative weightings/contributions of various parameters towards driving safety. Data indicative of a particular driver&#39;s behavior along a particular route during a particular set of conditions or contexts is obtained and compared to the analysis results to thereby determine or assess the driver&#39;s safety performance. The driver&#39;s safety performance may be evaluated in real-time, e.g., based on up-to-the-minute or currently obtained drivers&#39; data, so as to provide the driver with evaluation results, provide the driver with suggestions for improving driving safety, and/or automatically adjust an operation of the vehicle while the vehicle is traversing the particular route.

CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation of and claims priority to U.S.application Ser. No. 17/833,410 filed Jun. 6, 2022 and entitled “VehicleDriver Safety Performance Based On Relativity,” which is a continuationof and claims priority to U.S. application Ser. No. 15/592,503, filed onMay 11, 2017 and entitled “Vehicle Driver Safety Performance Based OnRelativity,” issued as U.S. Pat. No. 11,354,616 on Jun. 7, 2022, theentire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.

FIELD OF DISCLOSURE

The present disclosure generally relates to systems and methods fordetermining or rating a vehicle driver's safety performance in relationto other drivers' performances in similar contextual situations.

BACKGROUND

Vehicles are typically operated by a human vehicle operator (e.g., avehicle driver) who controls both steering and motive controls.Currently known methods for determining or rating a driver's performancetypically include collecting telematics data from the driver's vehiclewhile a driver operates the vehicle, and analyzing the collected data togenerate a rating or determination of the driver's performance inoperating the vehicle. Typical telematics data that is collected to ratea driver's performance includes vehicle movement data such as speed,acceleration, cornering, braking, and the like. Other data that isconventionally used in rating a driver's performance include the time ofday, miles traveled, and whether (or not) and/or where the vehicle isgaraged. Conventionally, a driver's performance rating is reflected byan average over a period of time, such as a six-month or yearly average.

SUMMARY

The present disclosure generally relates to systems and methods fordetermining or rating driver safety performance based on relativity,e.g., to other drivers and/or to particular combinations ofenvironmental conditions or contexts. Embodiments of example systems andmethods are summarized below. The methods and systems summarized belowmay include additional, less, or alternate actions, including thosediscussed elsewhere herein.

In an embodiment, a system for determining driver performance maycomprise one or more communication interfaces; an access mechanism to afirst set of data indicative of respective behavior of a plurality ofdrivers of a plurality of vehicles that traverse a plurality of routes,where the first set of data is based on data obtained by a set ofsensors while the plurality of drivers operate respective vehicles alongthe plurality of routes; one or more processors; one or morenon-transitory memories coupled to the one or more processors; andcomputer-executable instructions stored on the one or morenon-transitory memories thereby particularly configuring the one or morenon-transitory memories. The computer-executable instructions, whenexecuted by the one or more processors, may cause the system to collecta second set of data, where at least a portion of the second set of datais obtained by a set of sensors disposed at a particular vehicle that isoperated by a particular driver over a particular route, and each datapoint included in the second set of data is associated with a respectivegeospatial location included in the particular route; filter, using theaccess mechanism, the first set of data based on the particular route toobtain a subset of the first set of data corresponding to the particularroute; and analyze the subset of the first set of data corresponding tothe particular route to determine relative weightings amongst aplurality of different parameters whose values are included in thesubset of the first set of data, where the plurality of differentparameters is indicative of at least one of a behavior of the particulardriver, a behavior of the vehicle, or an environmental condition of theparticular route, and the relative weightings correspond to one or morelevels of driving performance. Additionally, the computer-executableinstructions, when executed by the one or more processors, may furthercause the system to compare the second set of data corresponding to theparticular driver with the analyzed subset of the first set of data;determine a level of driving performance of the particular driver basedon the comparison; and transmit an indication of the determined level ofdriving performance of the particular driver corresponding to theparticular route to at least one of: the particular vehicle operated bythe particular driver, a user interface, or another computing device orsystem.

In an embodiment, a method for determining driver performance maycomprise collecting, by one or more computing devices communicativelyconnected to a set of sensors disposed at a particular vehicle, a firstset of data, where at least a portion of the first set of data isobtained by the set of sensors while the particular vehicle is operatedby a particular driver over a particular route, and each data pointincluded in the first set of data is associated with a respectivegeospatial location included in the particular route; accessing a secondset of data indicative of respective behaviors of a plurality of driversof a plurality of vehicles traversing a plurality of routes, where thesecond set of data is based on data obtained by a plurality of sensorswhile the plurality of drivers operated respective vehicles along theplurality of routes, and the plurality of routes includes the particularroute; and filtering the second set of data based on the particularroute to obtain a subset of the second set of data corresponding to theparticular route. The method may further comprise analyzing the subsetof the second set of data corresponding to the particular route todetermine relative weightings amongst a plurality of differentparameters whose values are included in the subset of the second set ofdata, where the plurality of different parameters is indicative of atleast one of a behavior of the particular driver, a behavior of thevehicle, or an environmental condition of the particular route, and therelative weightings correspond to one or more levels of drivingperformance; comparing the first set of data corresponding to theparticular driver with analyzed subset of the second set of data;determining a level of driving performance of the particular driver forthe particular route based on the comparison; and transmitting anindication of the level of driving performance of the particular driverto at least one of: the particular vehicle being operated by theparticular driver, a user interface, or another computing device orsystem.

Systems or computer-readable media storing executable instructions forimplementing all or part of the systems and/or methods described hereinmay also be provided in some embodiments. Systems for implementing suchmethods may include one or more of the following: a special-purposecomputing device, a mobile computing device, a personal electronicdevice, an on-board computer, one or more remote servers or cloudcomputing system, one or more remote data storage entities, one or moresensors, one or more communication modules configured to communicatewirelessly via radio links, radio frequency links, and/or wirelesscommunication channels, and/or one or more non-transitory, tangibleprogram memories coupled to one or more processors of thespecial-purpose computing device, mobile computing device, personalelectronic device, on-board computer, and/or one or more remote serversor cloud computing system. Such program memories may store instructions,which, when executed by the one or more processors, may cause a systemdescribed herein to implement part or all of one or more methodsdescribed herein. Additional or alternative features described hereinbelow may be included in some embodiments.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

Advantages will become more apparent to those skilled in the art fromthe following description of the preferred embodiments which have beenshown and described by way of illustration. As will be realized, thepresent embodiments may be capable of other and different embodiments,and their details are capable of modification in various respects.Accordingly, the drawings and description are to be regarded asillustrative in nature and not as restrictive.

The figures described below depict various aspects of the applications,methods, and systems disclosed herein. It should be understood that eachfigure depicts an embodiment of a particular aspect of the disclosedapplications, systems and methods, and that each of the figures isintended to accord with a possible embodiment thereof. Furthermore,wherever possible, the following description refers to the referencenumerals included in the following figures, in which features depictedin multiple figures are designated with consistent reference numerals.

FIG. 1A illustrates a block diagram of an exemplary system fordetermining a vehicle driver's performance based on relativity;

FIG. 1B illustrates a more detailed block diagram of the back-endcomponents of the exemplary system shown in FIG. 1A;

FIG. 2 illustrates a block diagram of an exemplary mobile device oron-board computer that may operate in conjunction with the system ofFIGS. 1A and 1B;

FIG. 3 illustrates a flow diagram of an exemplary method for determiningvehicle driver's performance; and

FIG. 4 illustrates a flow diagram of an exemplary method for determiningvehicle driver's performance.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

Currently known techniques for determining or rating a driver'sperformance typically include collecting telematics data from a vehiclewhile a driver operates the vehicle, and analyzing the collected data togenerate a rating or determination of the driver's performance inoperating the vehicle. Typical telematics data that is collected to ratea driver's performance includes vehicle movement data such as speed,acceleration, cornering, braking, and the like, and comparing thecollected driver data against pre-determined thresholds. Other data thatis often used in rating a driver's performance include the time of day,miles traveled, and whether (or not) and/or where the vehicle isgaraged. Conventionally, a driver's performance rating is reflected byan average over a period of time, such as a six-month or yearly average.

An example of such an known method for determining or rating a driver'sperformance is described in U.S. Patent Publication No. 20160198306(“the '306 publication”), which shares a common assignee with thepresent disclosure, and whose contents are hereby incorporated byreference herein in their entirety. Generally speaking, the '306publication describes obtaining data from sensors disposed at a vehiclewhile a driver is operating the vehicle. The vehicle sensor data may beanalyzed together with relevant contextual data, such as data indicativeof the location and/or driving environment in which the driver isoperating the vehicle. Contextual data which may include, for example,the type of road on which the vehicle is traveling, the speed limit,traffic signs and lights, traffic density, weather, etc. Different“notable driving events,” such as instances of notable acceleration,braking, and cornering which may be indicative of unsafe behavior, aswell as the severity of such events, may be identified based on thevehicle sensor data, the contextual data, and pre-determined thresholdswhich delineate levels of safe driving behavior. For example, differentthresholds may be used for identifying a notable cornering driving eventin dry weather conditions, rainy weather conditions, and icy weatherconditions. In another example, different thresholds may be used foridentifying a notable braking driving event for highway driving,non-highway driving, low-traffic driving, high-traffic driving,approaching a stop sign intersection, approaching a stop lightintersection, etc. Thus, currently known techniques for determining orrating a driver's performance typically compare vehicle data that isobtained while the driver is operating the vehicle against one or morepre-determined thresholds to determine the driver's safety performance,and notable driving events which may be indicative of unsafe driverperformance may be determined based on the comparison of the driver'sdata against the pre-determined thresholds.

Currently known techniques, though, do not take into account how thevarious pre-determined threshold values are selected or set, and do nottake into account how various dynamic contextual conditions, eitheralone or in combination, affect how the values of the pre-determinedthresholds should be set. For example, in currently known techniques, afirst pre-determined threshold for a safe, maximum speed limit on aparticular stretch of highway may be defined for wet weather, and asecond, different pre-determined threshold for a safe, maximum speedlimit may be defined for the same stretch of highway for dry weather.However, in some situations, the safest speed at which a vehicle shouldbe traveling, e.g., for dry weather, is with the flow of traffic, whichmay be at a greater speed than the pre-determined “maximum safest dryweather speed” threshold. Currently known techniques are not able todistinguish such a situation, and would flag vehicle speed in excess ofthe pre-determined dry weather threshold as a potentially unsafe drivingevent. In another example, when a driver swerves to avoid an accident,currently known techniques may flag the swerve as an unsafe drivingevent due to the detected G-Force(s) exceeding a pre-determinedthreshold, even if the swerving may have been the safest course ofaction for the driver to take to avoid the accident for the given set ofconditions.

The novel techniques, systems, and methods disclosed herein, though, areable to determine optimal safe driving behaviors and optimal safetythresholds for various parameters in different contextual situationsand/or for different combinations of conditions along particular routes.Furthermore, unlike the currently known techniques for determining safedriver performance, the thresholds utilized by the novel techniques areable to be dynamically updated and adjusted in real-time and/or adriver's safety performance is able to be evaluated in real-time whilethe driver is operating a vehicle over a particular route so that thedriver may be provided with an indication of his or her current drivingsafety performance and/or with one or more suggestions that mayimmediately improve his or her driving safety while operating thevehicle over the particular route. Additionally or alternatively, insome embodiments, one or more operations of the vehicle may beautomatically adjusted or modified based on the current, detected driversafety performance while the driver is operating vehicle over theparticular route.

Accordingly, the present disclosure is able to provide a more accurateor granular determination of a driver's safety performance, which maythen be utilized for any number of useful applications such asdetermining risk, adjusting operations of the vehicle and/or of othersurrounding vehicles (e.g., of fully and/or semi-autonomous vehiclesoperating in the vicinity of the vehicle), training and/or educating thedriver, and the like. Generally speaking, the novel techniques, systemsand methods disclosed herein may determine or rate a driver's safetyperformance based on relativity to other drivers' behavior in similarsituations, and/or based on relative weights of the respective impact ofdifferent contextual conditions on driver safety.

FIG. 1A illustrates a block diagram of an exemplary system 100 fordetermining the performance of the driver of a vehicle based onrelativity. The high-level architecture illustrated in FIG. 1A mayinclude both hardware and software applications, as well as various datacommunications channels for communicating data between the varioushardware and software components, as is described below. The system 100may be roughly divided into front-end components 102 and back-endcomponents 104. The front-end components 102 may obtain informationregarding a vehicle 108 (e.g., a car, truck, motorcycle, etc.) that isbeing operated by driver and regarding the context and surroundingenvironment in which the vehicle 108 is being operated. One or moreon-board computers 110 and/or one or more mobile devices 112 that areincluded in the front-end components 102 and disposed at the vehicle 108may utilize this information to, for example, notify or alert the driverof the vehicle 108, notify or alert other drivers and other vehicles 115a-115 n that are operating in the surrounding environment, automaticallychange an operating behavior of the vehicle 108 and/or of any one ormore of the other vehicles 115 a-115 n, and/or to assist the driver inoperating the vehicle 108. The one or more on-board computers 110 may bepermanently or removably installed in the vehicle 108, and the one ormore mobile devices 112 may be disposed at and transported by thevehicle 108, for example.

Generally speaking, the on-board computer 110 may be an on-boardcomputing device capable of performing various functions relating tovehicle operations and determining driver performance. That is, theon-board computer 110 may be particularly configured with particularelements to thereby be able to perform functions relating to determiningdriver performance and/or vehicle operations. Further, the on-boardcomputer 110 may be installed by the manufacturer of the vehicle 108, oras an aftermarket modification or addition to the vehicle 108. In FIG.1A, although only one on-board computer 110 is depicted, it should beunderstood that in some embodiments, a plurality of on-board computers110 (which may be installed at one or more locations within the vehicle108) may be used. However, for ease of reading and not for limitationpurposes, the on-board computing device or computer 110 is referred toherein using the singular tense.

The mobile device 112 may be transported by the vehicle 108 and may be,for example, a personal computer or personal electronic device (PED),cellular phone, smart phone, tablet computer, smart watch, wearableelectronics, or a dedicated vehicle monitoring or control device whichmay be releasably attached to the vehicle 108. Although only one mobiledevice 112 is illustrated in FIG. 1A, it should be understood that insome embodiments, a plurality of mobile devices 112 may be included inthe system 100. For ease of reading and not for limitation purposes,though, the mobile device 112 is referred to herein using the singulartense.

Further, it is noted that, in some embodiments, the on-board computer110 may operate in conjunction with the mobile device 112 to perform anyor all of the functions described herein as being performed on-board thevehicle 108. In other embodiments, the on-board computer 110 may performall of the on-board vehicle functions described herein, in which caseeither no mobile device 112 is being transported by the vehicle 108, orany mobile device 112 that is being transported by the vehicle 108 isignorant or unaware of vehicle and driver operations. In still otherembodiments, the mobile device 112 may perform all of the onboardvehicle functions described herein. Still further, in some embodiments,the on-board computer 110 and/or the mobile device 112 may perform anyor all of the functions described herein in conjunction with one or moreback-end components 104. For example, in some embodiments or undercertain conditions, the mobile device 112 and/or on-board computer 110may function as thin-client devices that outsource some or most of theprocessing to one or more of the back-end components 104.

At any rate, the on-board computing device 110 and/or the mobile device112 disposed at the vehicle 108 may communicatively interface with oneor more on-board sensors 118 that are disposed on or within the vehicle108 and that may be utilized to monitor the vehicle 108 and theenvironment in which the vehicle 108 is operating. That is, the one ormore on-board sensors 118 may sense conditions associated with thevehicle 108 and/or associated with the environment in which the vehicle108 is operating, and may collect data indicative of the sensedconditions. In some configurations, at least some of the on-boardsensors 118 may be fixedly disposed at various locations on the vehicle108. Additionally or alternatively, at least some of the on-boardsensors may be incorporated within or connected to the on-board computer110. Still additionally or alternatively, in some configurations, atleast some of the on-board sensors 118 may be included on or within themobile device 112. Whether disposed at or on the vehicle 108 or disposedat or on a mobile device 112 being transported by the vehicle 108,though, the one or more of the sensors 118 are generally referred toherein as “on-board sensors 118,” and the data collected by the on-boardsensors 118 is generally referred to herein as “sensor data,” “on-boardsensor data,” or “vehicle sensor data.” The on-board sensors 118 maycommunicate respective sensor data to the on-board computer 110 and/orto the mobile device 112, and the sensor data may be processed using theon-board computer 110 and/or the mobile device 112 to determine when thevehicle is in operation as well as determine information regarding thevehicle 108, the vehicle's operating behavior, and/or the driver'soperating behavior and performance. In some situations, the on-boardsensors 118 may communicate respective sensor data indicative of theenvironment in which the vehicle 108 is operating.

As discussed above, at least some of the on-board sensors 118 associatedwith the vehicle 108 may be removably or fixedly disposed within or atthe vehicle 108, and further may be disposed in various arrangements andat various locations to sense and provide information. The sensors 118that are installed at the vehicle 108 may include one or more of a GPSunit, a radar unit, a LIDAR unit, an ultrasonic sensor, an infraredsensor, some other type of electromagnetic energy sensor, an inductancesensor, a camera, an accelerometer, an odometer, a system clock, agyroscope, a compass, a geo-location or geo-positioning unit, a locationtracking sensor, a proximity sensor, a tachometer, and/or a speedometer,to name a few. Some of the on-board sensors 118 (e.g., GPS,accelerometer, or tachometer units) may provide sensor data indicativeof, for example, the vehicle's location, speed, position acceleration,direction, responsiveness to controls, movement, etc. Other sensors 118that are disposed at the vehicle 108 may be directed to the interior orpassenger compartment of the vehicle 108, such as cameras, microphones,pressure sensors, weight sensors, thermometers, or similar sensors tomonitor the vehicle operator, any passengers, operations of instrumentsincluded in the vehicle, operational behaviors of the vehicle, and/orconditions within the vehicle 108. For example, on-board sensors 118directed to the interior of the vehicle 108 may provide sensor dataindicative of, for example, in-cabin temperatures, in-cabin noiselevels, data from seat sensors (e.g., indicative of whether or not aperson is using a seat, and thus the number of passengers beingtransported by the vehicle 108), data from seat belt sensors, dataregarding the operations of user controlled devices such as windshieldwipers, defrosters, traction control, mirror adjustment, interactionswith on-board user interfaces, etc. Some of the sensors 118 disposed atthe vehicle 108 (e.g., radar, LIDAR, camera, or other types of unitsthat operate by using electromagnetic energy) may actively or passivelyscan the environment external to the vehicle 108 for obstacles (e.g.,other vehicles, buildings, pedestrians, trees, gates, barriers, animals,etc.) and their movement, weather conditions (e.g., precipitation, wind,visibility, or temperature), roadways, road conditions (e.g., lanemarkings, potholes, road material, traction, or slope), road topography,traffic conditions (e.g., traffic density, traffic congestion, etc.),signs or signals (e.g., traffic signals, speed limits, otherjurisdictional signage, construction signs, building signs or numbers,or control gates), and/or other information indicative of the vehicle'senvironment. Information or data that is generated or received by theon-board sensors 118 may be communicated to the on-board computer 110and/or to the mobile device 112, for example.

In some embodiments of the system 100, the front-end components 102 maycommunicate collected sensor data to the back-end components 104, e.g.,via a network 120. For example, at least one of the on-board computer110 or the mobile device 112 may communicate with the back-endcomponents 104 via the network 120 to allow the back-end components 104to record collected sensor data and information regarding vehicle usage.The network 120 may include a proprietary network, a secure publicinternet, a virtual private network, and/or some other type of network,such as dedicated access lines, plain ordinary telephone lines,satellite links, cellular data networks, combinations of these and/orother types of networks. The network 120 may utilize one or more radiofrequency communication links to communicatively connect to the vehicle108, e.g., utilize wireless communication links 122 and 125 tocommunicatively connect with mobile device 112 and on-board computer110, respectively. Where the network 120 comprises the Internet or otherdata packet network, data communications may take place over the network120 via an Internet or other suitable data packet communicationprotocol. In some arrangements, the network 120 additionally oralternatively includes one or more wired communication links ornetworks.

The back-end components 104 include one or more servers or computingdevices, which may be implemented as a server bank or cloud computingsystem 130, and is interchangeably referred to herein as a “remotecomputing system 130.” The remote computing system 130 may include oneor more computer processors adapted and configured to execute varioussoftware applications and components of the system 100, in addition toother software applications. The remote computing system 130 may furtherinclude or be communicatively connected to one or more data storagedevices or entities 132, which may be adapted to store data related tothe operation of the vehicle 108, driver performance, the environmentand context in which the vehicle 108 is operating, and/or otherinformation. For example, the one or more data storage devices 132 maybe implemented as a data bank or a cloud data storage system, at least aportion of which may be included in and/or locally accessed by theremote computing system 130 (for example, as illustrated in FIG. 1A)using a local access mechanism such as a function call or databaseaccess mechanism, and/or at least a portion of which may be remotelyaccessed by the remote computing system 130 (for example, as illustratedin FIG. 1B) using a remote access mechanism such as a communicationprotocol. Thus, although only one data storage device 132 is illustratedin FIGS. 1A and 1B, it is understood that in some embodiments, aplurality of data storage devices or entities 132 may be included in thesystem 100. For ease of reading and not for limitation purposes, though,the data storage device 132 is referred to herein using the singulartense. The remote computing system 130 may access data stored in thedata storage device 132 when executing various functions and tasksassociated with the present disclosure.

To communicate with the remote computing system 130 and other portionsof the back-end components 104, the front-end components 102 may includeone or more communication components 135 a, 135 b that are configured totransmit information to and receive information from the back-endcomponents 104 and, in some embodiments, transmit information to andreceive information from other external sources, such as other vehiclesand/or infrastructure or environmental components disposed within thevehicle's environment. The one or more communication components 135 a,135 b may include one or more wireless transmitters or transceiversoperating at any desired or suitable frequency or frequencies. Differentwireless transmitters or transceivers may operate at differentfrequencies and/or by using different protocols, if desired. In anexample, the mobile device 112 may include a respective communicationcomponent 135 a for sending or receiving information to and from theremote computing system 130 via the network 120, such as over one ormore radio frequency links or wireless communication channels 122 whichsupport a first communication protocol (e.g., GSM, CDMA, LTE, one ormore IEEE 802.11 Standards such as Wi-Fi, WiMAX, BLUETOOTH, etc.).Additionally or alternatively, the on-board computer 110 may operate inconjunction with an on-board transceiver or transmitter 135 b that isdisposed at the vehicle 108 (which may, for example, be fixedly attachedto the vehicle 108) for sending or receiving information to and from theremote computing system 130 via the network 120, such as over one ormore radio frequency links or wireless communication channels 125 whichsupport the first communication protocol and/or a second communicationprotocol. In some embodiments, the on-board computer 110 may operate inconjunction with the mobile device 112 to utilize the communicationcomponent 135 a of the mobile device 112 and the link 122 to deliverinformation to the back-end components 104. In some embodiments, theon-board computer 110 may operate in conjunction with the mobile device112 to utilize the communication component 135 b of the vehicle 108 andthe link 125 to deliver information to the back-end components 104. Insome embodiments, both communication components 135 a, 135 b and theirrespective links 122, 125 may be utilized by the on-board computer 110and/or the mobile device 112 to communicate with the back-end components104.

Accordingly, either one or both of the mobile device 112 or on-boardcomputer 110 may communicate with the network 120 over the links 122and/or 125. Additionally, in some configurations, the mobile device 112and on-board computer 110 may communicate with one another directly overa link 138, which may be a wireless or wired link.

In some embodiments of the system 100, the on-board computer 110 and/orthe on-board mobile device 112 of the vehicle 108 may communicate withrespective on-board computers and/or mobile devices disposed at one ormore other vehicles 115 a-115 n, either directly or via the network 120.For example, the on-board computer 110 and/or the mobile device 112disposed at the vehicle 108 may communicate with other vehicles'respective on-board computers and/or mobile devices via the network 120and one or more of the communication components 135 a, 135 b by usingone or more suitable wireless communication protocols (e.g., GSM, CDMA,LTE, one or more IEEE 802.11 Standards such as Wi-Fi, WiMAX, BLUETOOTH,etc.). In some configurations, the on-board computer 110 may communicatewith a particular vehicle 115 a-115 n directly in a peer-to-peer (P2P)manner via one or more of the communication components 135 a, 135 b andthe direct wireless communication link 140, which may utilize, forexample, a Wi-Fi direct protocol, a BLUETOOTH or other short rangecommunication protocol, an ad-hoc cellular communication protocol, orany other suitable wireless communication protocol.

In some embodiments, the system 100 may include one or moreenvironmental communication components or devices, examples of which aredepicted in FIG. 1A by references 142 a, 142 b, 142 c, that are used formonitoring the status of one or more infrastructure components 145and/or for receiving data generated by other sensors 150 that areassociated with the vehicle 108 and disposed at locations that areoff-board the vehicle 108. As generally referred to herein, with respectto the vehicle 108, “off-board sensors” or “environmental sensors” 150are sensors that are not being transported by the vehicle 108. The datacollected by the off-board sensors 150 is generally referred to hereinas “sensor data,” “off-board sensor data,” or “environmental sensordata” with respect to the vehicle 108.

At least some of the off-board sensors 150 may be disposed on or at theone or more infrastructure components 145 or other types of componentsthat are fixedly disposed within the environment in which the vehicle108 is traveling. Infrastructure components 145 may include roadways,bridges, traffic signals, gates, switches, crossings, parking lots orgarages, toll booths, docks, hangars, or other similar physical portionsof a transportation system's infrastructure, for example. Other types ofinfrastructure components 145 at which off-board sensors 150 may bedisposed may include a traffic light, a street sign, a railroad crossingsignal, a construction notification sign, a roadside display configuredto display messages, a billboard display, a parking garage monitoringdevice, etc. Off-board sensors 150 that are disposed on or nearinfrastructure components 145 may generate data relating to the presenceand location of obstacles or of the infrastructure component 145 itself,weather conditions, traffic conditions, operating status of theinfrastructure component 145, and/or behaviors of various vehicles 108,115 a-115 n, pedestrians, and/or other moving objects within thevicinity of the infrastructure component 145, for example.

Additionally or alternatively, at least some of the off-board sensors150 that are communicatively connected to the one or more infrastructuredevices 145 may be disposed on or at one or more other vehicles 115a-115 n operating in the vicinity of the vehicle 108. As such, aparticular sensor that is disposed on-board another vehicle 115 a may beviewed as an off-board sensor 150 with respect to the vehicle 108.

At any rate, the one or more environmental communication devices 142a-142 c that are associated with the vehicle 108 may be communicativelyconnected (either directly or indirectly) to one or more off-boardsensors 150, and thereby may receive information relating to thecondition and/or location of the infrastructure components 145, of theenvironment surrounding the infrastructure components 145, and/or ofother vehicles 115 a-115 n or objects within the environment of thevehicle 108. In some embodiments, the one or more environmentalcommunication devices 142 a-142 c may receive information from thevehicle 108, while, in other embodiments, the environmentalcommunication device(s) 142 a-142 c may only transmit information to thevehicle 108. As previously discussed, at least some of the environmentalcommunication devices may be locally disposed in the environment inwhich the vehicle 108 is operating, e.g., as denoted by references 142a, 142 b. In some embodiments, at least some of the environmentalcommunication devices may be remotely disposed, e.g., at the back-end104 of the system 100 as denoted by reference 142 c. In someembodiments, at least a portion of the environmental communicationdevices may be included in (e.g., integral with) one or more off-boardsensors 150, e.g., as denoted by reference 142 b. In someconfigurations, at least some of the environmental communication devices142 may be included or integrated into the one or more on-boardcommunication components 135 a, 135 b, the on-board computer 110, and/orthe mobile device 112 of surrounding vehicles 115 a-115 n (not shown).

In addition to receiving information from the on-board sensors 118 andoff-board sensors 150 associated with the vehicle 108, the on-boardcomputer 110 at the vehicle 108 may directly or indirectly control theoperation of the vehicle 108 according to various fully- orsemi-autonomous operation features. The autonomous operation featuresmay include software applications or modules implemented by the on-boardcomputer 110 to generate and implement control commands to control thesteering, braking, or motive power of the vehicle 108. To facilitatesuch control, the on-board computer 110 may be communicatively connectedto control components of the vehicle 108 by various electrical orelectromechanical control components (not shown). When a control commandis generated by the on-board computer 110, it may thus be communicatedto the control components of the vehicle 108 to effect a control action.In embodiments involving fully autonomous vehicles, the vehicle 108 maybe operable only through such control components (not shown). In otherembodiments, the control components may be disposed within or supplementother vehicle operator control components (not shown), such as steeringwheels, accelerator or brake pedals, or ignition switches.

Further, the on-board computer 110 may control one or more operations ofthe vehicle 108 when the vehicle is operating non-autonomously. Forexample, the on-board computer 110 may automatically detect respectivetriggering conditions and automatically activate corresponding featuressuch as traction control, windshield wipers, headlights, braking, etc.

FIG. 1B depicts a more detailed block diagram of the example back-endcomponents 104 of the system 100. As shown in FIG. 1B, the remotecomputing system 130 included in the back-end components 104 may have acontroller 151 that is operatively connected to the data storage device132 via a link 152, which may be include a local and/or a remote link.It should be noted that, while not shown, additional data storagedevices or entities may be linked to the controller 151 in a knownmanner. For example, separate, additional databases and/or data storagedevices (not shown) may be used for various types of information, suchas autonomous operation feature information, vehicle accidents, roadconditions, vehicle insurance policy information, driver performance, orvehicle use information. Additional databases or data storage devices(not shown) may be communicatively connected to the remote computingsystem 130 via the network 120, such as databases maintained by thirdparties (e.g., weather databases, road construction databases, trafficcongestion databases, road network databases, IoT (Internet-of-Things)or sensor databases implemented by a city or other jurisdiction, etc.).

The controller 151 may include one or more memories 160 (e.g., one ormore program memories 160), one or more processors 162 (which may becalled a microcontroller or a microprocessor), one or more random-accessmemories (RAMs) 164, and an input/output (I/O) circuit 166, all of whichmay be interconnected via an address/data bus 165. It should beappreciated that although only one microprocessor 162 is shown, thecontroller 151 may include multiple microprocessors 162. Similarly, thememory of the controller 151 may include multiple RAMs 164 and multipleprogram memories 160. Although the I/O circuit 166 is shown as a singleblock, it should be appreciated that the I/O circuit 166 may include anumber of different types of I/O circuits. The RAM 164 and programmemories 160 may be implemented as semiconductor memories, magneticallyreadable memories, optically readable memories, or biologically readablememories, for example. Generally speaking, the RAM 164 and/or theprogram memories 160 may respectively include one or morenon-transitory, computer-readable storage media. The controller 151 mayalso be operatively connected to the network 120 via a link 170.

The remote computing system 130 may further include a number ofapplications 155 a-155 h stored in a program memory 160. In anembodiment, the applications 155 a-155 h comprise one or more softwareapplications or sets of computer-executable instructions that are storedon the program memory 160 and executable by the processor 162. In anembodiment, at least some of the applications 155 a-155 h may beimplemented at least partially in firmware and/or in hardware at theremote computing system 130.

The various applications 155 a-155 h on the remote computing system 130may include, for example, a vehicle monitoring application 155 a forreceiving sensor data, whether from on-board sensors 118 and/or fromoff-board sensors 150, that is indicative of the operating behavior ofthe vehicle 108 and/or of its driver. The remote computing system 130may also include an environmental monitoring application 155 b forreceiving data, whether from on-board sensors 118, off-board sensors150, and/or third-party data feeds (not illustrated in FIG. 1A), that isindicative of environmental and contextual conditions in which thevehicle 108 is operating. Additionally, the remote computing system 130may include a filtering application 155 c for filtering a set ofhistorical data based on a driving route and optionally otherconditions, a weights generator application 155 d for determiningrelative weightings of various conditions with respect to safety, adriver safety performance evaluation application 155 e for determining aperformance of the driver of the vehicle 108, and a real-timecommunication application 155 f for communicating information and/orinstructions to the vehicle 108 (e.g., to the on-board computing device110, the mobile device 112, and/or another computing device disposed atthe vehicle 108), to other vehicles 115 a-115 n, and/or to othercomputing systems. Other applications at the remote computing system 130may include, for example, an application for supporting autonomousand/or semi-autonomous vehicle operations 155 g and/or one or more otherapplications 155 h which may support vehicle operations (whether fully-,semi- or non-autonomous) and other functions. Generally speaking, theapplications 155 a-155 h may perform one or more functions related toevaluating driver safety performance. For example, one or more of theapplications 155 a-155 h may perform at least a portion of any of themethods described herein.

The various modules or software applications 155 a-155 h may be executedon the same computer processor 162 or on different computer processors.Further, while the various applications 155 a-155 h are depicted asseparate applications, two or more of the applications 155 a-155 h maybe integrated as an integral application, if desired. In someembodiments, at least one of the applications 155 a-155 h may beimplemented in conjunction with another application (not shown) that isstored and executed at the remote computing system 130, such as anavigation application.

The data storage device 132 is particularly configured to store varioustypes of data related to and used for vehicle driver safety performanceevaluation. For example, driver route data 175 may be stored at the datastorage device 132. Driver route data 175 may include data that isindicative of the behavior of a driver and/or the behavior of thevehicle 108 while the vehicle 108 is being operated over a particularroute, e.g., data that is sensed by on-board sensors 118 and/or byoff-board sensors 150. Additionally, driver route data 175 may includedata that is indicative of contextual or environmental conditionsoccurring while the vehicle 108 is being operated over the particularroute, e.g., data that is provided by onboard sensors 118, off-boardsensors 150, and/or third-party data feeds. Generally, each data pointincluded in the driver route data 175 is time-stamped and includes anindication of a respective geo-location at which the data point wascollected. That is, at least a portion of the driver route data 175 mayinclude time-series data.

The data storage device 132 may also include historical driver data 178.Historical driver data 178 may include data that is indicative ofdriving behavior, vehicle operations, and environmental contexts inwhich multiple vehicles have traveled, e.g., along multiple routes andover multiple periods of time. For example, the historical driver data178 may include respective driver route data 175 for a plurality ofdrivers of a plurality of vehicles over a plurality of routes and over aplurality of different periods of time. Each data point included in thehistorical driver data 178 may be associated with a respective timestampan indication of a respective geo-location associated therewith, whichmay be indicative of the time in geo-location at which the data pointwas collected or obtained. That is, at least a portion of the historicaldriver data 178 may include time-series data.

In some embodiments, the data storage device 132 may include filtereddata 180, which generally is a subset of the historical driver data 178.The historical driver data 178 may be filtered based on one or moreconditions or parameters to generate the filtered data 180. For example,the filtered data 180 may be generated by filtering the historicaldriver data 178 based on a particular route, a time of day of travel, aparticular weather condition, an amount of traffic congestion, whetherthe corresponding vehicle is an automobile or a truck, etc. Additionallyor alternatively, the data storage device 132 may store a set of weights182, which may correspond to various driving conditions and/orparameters. In an embodiment, the set of weights 182 may be included ina safe driver model 185, which may also be stored at the data storagedevice 182. Descriptions and usage of the filtered data 180, the set ofweights 182, and the safe driver model 185 are described in latersections of this disclosure.

Additionally, it is noted that although the system 100 for determiningdriver performance 100 is shown in FIGS. 1A and 1B to include onevehicle 108, one mobile device 112, one on-board computer 110, and oneremote computing system 130, it should be understood that differentnumbers of vehicles 108, mobile devices 112, on-board computers 110,and/or remote computing devices or servers 130 may be utilized. Forexample, the system 100 may include a plurality of servers 130 andhundreds or thousands of mobile devices 112 or on-board computers 110,all of which may be interconnected via the network 120. Furthermore, thedatabase storage or processing performed by the one or more servers 130may be distributed among a plurality of servers 130 in an arrangementknown as “cloud computing.” This configuration may provide variousadvantages, such as enabling near real-time uploads and downloads ofinformation as well as periodic uploads and downloads of information.This may in turn support a thin-client embodiment of the mobile device112 or on-board computer 110 discussed herein. Further, in someembodiments, any number of other vehicles 115 a-115 n may becommunicatively connected to and/or included in the system 100, e.g.,via the network 120.

FIG. 2 illustrates a block diagram of an exemplary mobile device 112 oran exemplary on-board computer 110 consistent with the system 100. Themobile device 112 or on-board computer 110 may include a display 202, aGPS or other suitable geo-location unit 206, a communication unit 220,an accelerometer 224, one or more additional sensors 225, a user-inputdevice (not shown), and/or a controller 204, similar to the controller151 in the remote computing system 130. In some embodiments, the mobiledevice 112 and on-board computer 110 may be integrated into a singledevice, or either may perform the functions of both. The on-boardcomputer 110/mobile device 112 may interface with one or more on-boardsensors 118 that are disposed at the vehicle 108 (but that are separatefrom the device 110/112) to receive information regarding the vehicle108 and its environment. Additionally, the on-board computer 110/mobiledevice 112 may interface with one or more off-board sensors 150 toreceive information regarding the vehicle 108 and its environment.

Similar to the controller 151, the controller 204 may include a programmemory 208, one or more microcontrollers or microprocessors (MP) 210, aRAM 212, and an I/O circuit 216, all of which are interconnected via anaddress/data bus 214. The program memory 208 includes an operatingsystem 226, a data storage 228, and/or a plurality of softwareapplications 230. The operating system 226, for example, may include oneof a plurality of general purpose or mobile platforms, such as theAndroid™ iOS®, or Windows® systems, developed by Google Inc., AppleInc., and Microsoft Corporation, respectively. Alternatively, theoperating system 226 may be a custom operating system designed for theon-board computer 110. The data storage 228 may include data such asuser profiles and preferences, application data for the plurality ofapplications 230, and other data related to evaluating driverperformance. In some embodiments, the controller 204 may also include,or otherwise be communicatively connected to, other data storagemechanisms (e.g., one or more hard disk drives, optical storage drives,solid state storage devices, etc.) that reside within the vehicle 108and/or at the remote system 130.

As discussed with reference to the controller 151, it should beappreciated that although FIG. 2 depicts only one microprocessor 210,the controller 204 may include multiple microprocessors 210. Similarly,the memory of the controller 204 may include multiple RAMs 212 andmultiple program memories 208. Although FIG. 2 depicts the I/O circuit216 as a single block, the I/O circuit 216 may include a number ofdifferent types of I/O circuits. The controller 204 may implement theRAMs 212 and the program memories 208 as semiconductor memories,magnetically readable memories, or optically readable memories, forexample. Generally speaking, the RAMs 212 and/or the program memories208 may respectively include one or more non-transitory,computer-readable storage media.

The one or more processors 210 of the device 110/112 may be adapted andconfigured to execute any of one or more of the plurality of softwareapplications 230 residing in the program memory 204, in addition toother software applications. The various software applications 230 ofthe device 110/112 may include, for example, a vehicle monitoringapplication 231 for receiving (whether from on-board sensors 118 and/orfrom off-board sensors 150) sensor data indicative of the operatingbehavior of the vehicle 108 and/or of the driver, an environmentalmonitoring application 232 for receiving (whether from on-board sensors118, off-board sensors 150, and/or third-party data feeds) dataindicative of environmental and contextual conditions in which thevehicle 108 is operating, a filtering application 233 for filtering aset of historical data based on a driving route and optionally otherconditions, a weights generator application 234 for determining relativeweightings of various conditions with respect to safety, a driver safetyperformance evaluation application 235 for determining a performance ofthe driver of the vehicle 108, and a real-time communication application236 for communicating information and/or instructions to the vehicle 108(e.g., to another computing device or system disposed at the vehicle108), to other vehicles 115 a-115 n, to the remote computing system 130,to other back-end components 104 of the system 100 such as theenvironmental communication device 142 c, and/or to other computingsystems. Other applications that are executed at the device 110/112 mayinclude, for example, an application for supporting autonomous and/orsemi-autonomous vehicle operations 237 and/or one or more otherapplications 238 which may support vehicle operations (whether fully-,semi-, or non-autonomous). Generally speaking, the applications 230 mayperform one or more functions related to evaluating driver safetyperformance. For example, one or more of the applications 230 mayperform at least a portion of any of the methods described herein. Insome embodiments, one or more of the applications 230 may operate inconjunction with one or more of the applications 155 a-155 h at theremote computing system 130 to perform one or more functions related toevaluating driver safety performance. For example, one or more of theapplications 231-238 at the device 110/112 may be implemented as athin-client that operates in conjunction with one or more of theapplications 231-238 at the remote computing system.

The various software applications 230 may be executed on the samecomputer processor 210 or on different computer processors. Further,while the various applications 231-238 are depicted as separateapplications, two or more of the applications 231-238 may be integratedas an integral application, if desired. In some embodiments, at leastone of the applications 231-238 may be implemented in conjunction withanother application (not shown) that is stored and executed at thedevice 110/112, e.g., a navigation application, a user interfaceapplication, etc.

In addition to the communicative connections to the on-board sensors 118that are disposed at the vehicle 108 but not at, on, or within thedevice 110/112 itself, the device 110/112 may include additionalon-board sensors 118 that are integral with the device 110/112, such asthe GPS unit 206 and/or the accelerometer 224, which may provideinformation regarding the operation of the vehicle 108. Such integralsensors 118 may further include one or more sensors of a sensor array225, which may include, for example, one or more cameras, additionalaccelerometers, gyroscopes, magnetometers, barometers, thermometers,proximity sensors, light sensors, Hall Effect sensors, etc. The one ormore sensors of the sensor array 225 may be positioned to determinetelematics data regarding the speed, force, heading, direction, and/orother parameters associated with movements of the vehicle 108.

Furthermore, the communication unit 220 of the device 110/112 maycommunicate with other vehicles 115 a-115 n, infrastructure orenvironmental components 142, 145, back-end components 104, or otherexternal sources of information to transmit and receive informationrelating to evaluating driver performance. For example, thecommunication unit 220 may be included in or may include one or more ofthe communication components 135 a, 135 b shown in FIG. 1A. Additionallyor alternatively, the communication unit 220 may be included in or mayinclude an instance of the environmental communication component 142shown in FIG. 1A. The communication unit 220 may communicate with theexternal sources via the network 120 or via any suitable wirelesscommunication protocol network, such as wireless telephony (e.g., GSM,CDMA, LTE, etc.), Wi-Fi (802.11 standards), WiMAX, Bluetooth, infraredor radio frequency communication, etc. Further, the communication unit220 may provide input signals to the controller 204 via the I/O circuit216. The communication unit 220 may also transmit sensor data, devicestatus information, control signals, or other output from the controller204 to one or more sensors 118 within the vehicle 108, mobile devices112, on-board computers 110, off-board sensors 150, environmentalcommunication devices 142, and/or remote servers 130.

Further, the mobile device 112 or the on-board computer 110 may includea user-input device (not shown) for receiving instructions orinformation from the vehicle operator, such as settings, selections,acknowledgements, etc. The user-input device (not shown) may include a“soft” keyboard that is displayed on the display 202, an externalhardware keyboard communicating via a wired or a wireless connection(e.g., a Bluetooth keyboard), an external mouse, a microphone, or anyother suitable user-input device. The user-input device (not shown) mayalso include a microphone capable of receiving user voice input.

FIG. 3 depicts a flow diagram of an exemplary method 300 for determiningthe safety performance of a driver of a vehicle, such as the vehicle 108of FIG. 1A. At least a portion of the method 300 may be performed by thesystem 100 of FIGS. 1A and 1B, for example, by the on-board computer110, the on-board mobile device 112, and/or the remote computing devices130. For ease of discussion, and not for limitation purposes, the method300 is discussed with simultaneous reference to the system 100, althoughit is understood that the method 300 may operate in conjunction withother systems and/or computing devices.

At a block 302, the method 300 may include collecting driver route data(e.g., driver route data 175) that is associated with a vehicle, such asthe vehicle 108. Generally speaking, the driver route data 175 mayinclude data that is indicative of a behavior of the vehicle 108, abehavior of the driver of the vehicle 108, and/or various contextual andenvironmental conditions occurring while the vehicle is operated along aparticular route over a particular time period or interval. The driverroute data 175 may include data collected from one or more sensors thatare disposed on-board the vehicle 108 (e.g., the on-board sensors 118),data collected from one or more sensors that are disposed off-board thevehicle 108 (e.g., the off-board sensors 150), and/or third-partygenerated data that is indicative of environmental and/or contextualconditions occurring along the particular route during the particulartime period or interval. Third-party data may include, for example, datathat is stored in databases maintained by third parties, e.g., weatherdatabases, road construction databases, traffic congestion databases,road network databases, IoT or sensor databases implemented by a city orother jurisdiction, etc., and that is provided via a data feed to thesystem 100, e.g., via the network 120. Some or all of the data pointsincluded in the driver route data 175 may include respective indicationsof a time and a geo-location at which the data point was collected orobserved. That is, at least some of the driver route data 175 may betime-series data.

The driver route data 175 may include data that is indicative of avehicle's position, speed, acceleration, direction, movement, and/orresponsiveness to controls. Additionally or alternatively, the driverroute data 175 collected at the block 302 may include data that isindicative of users and/or human presence within the vehicle 108, suchas data indicative of in-cabin temperatures, in-cabin noise levels, datafrom seat sensors (e.g., indicative of whether or not a person is usinga seat, and thus the number of passengers being transported by thevehicle 108), data from seat belt sensors, data regarding the operationsof user controlled devices such as windshield wipers, defrosters,traction control, mirror adjustment, interactions with on-board userinterfaces, etc. In some embodiments, the driver route data 175 mayinclude data that is indicative of various contextual or environmentalconditions of the particular route during the particular time interval,e.g., weather changes and/or conditions, road conditions, roadconfigurations (e.g., merging lanes, construction zones, etc.), trafficdensity, pedestrian density, density of other humans (e.g., cyclists,skateboarders, etc.), posted speed limits and other trafficsigns/lights, school zones, railroad tracks, traffic accidents, etc.

At a block 305, the method 300 may include accessing historical driverdata 178 that includes data indicative of driving behavior, vehicleoperations and behavior, and/or environmental conditions and contextsobtained for multiple drivers of multiple vehicles along multiple routesand over multiple periods or intervals of time. The historical driverdata 178 may be stored at and accessed from the data storage device 132,for example, e.g., by utilizing any suitable local access mechanism(e.g., a function call, a database read, an API (Application ProgrammingInterface), etc.) and/or any suitable remote access mechanism (e.g., amessage exchange using a communication protocol, a remote API, etc.). Inan embodiment, the historical driver data 178 may include respectivedriver route data 175 corresponding to a plurality of drivers of aplurality of vehicles over a plurality of routes and over a plurality ofdifferent periods of time or different time intervals. At least some ofthe historical driver data 178 may have been generated by and/orcollected from multiple sets of sensors associated with multiplevehicles 108, 115 a-115 n (e.g., on-board sensors 118, off-board sensors150, etc.). At least some of the historical driver data 178 may includethird-party data that may have been generated and provided by one ormore third-party data providers. Typically, third-party data includesdata that is indicative of one or more environmental or contextualconditions occurring along various routes in various intervals of time.Third-party data may include, for example, data from weather databases,road construction databases, traffic congestion databases, road networkdatabases, IoT or sensor databases implemented by a city or otherjurisdiction, etc. Third-party data may be stored in databasesmaintained by third-parties (e.g., a party or entity other than thatproviding the system 100), and the third-party data may be provided tothe system 100, e.g., as a data feed via the network 120. In anembodiment, each data point included in the historical driver data 178,whether sensed or obtain via third party, may have a respectivetimestamp and indication of a respective geo-location associatedtherewith, which may be indicative of the time and geo-location at whichthe respective data point was collected or obtained. As such, at least aportion of the historical driver data 178 may be time-series data.

At a block 308, the method 300 may include filtering the historicaldriver data 178 based on at least a portion of the information includedin the driver route data 175 to obtain a subset 180 of the historicaldriver data 178 that corresponds to the driver route data 175. In anembodiment, the historical driver data 178 may be filtered based on theparticular route identified in the driver route data 175. Additionallyor alternatively, the historical driver data 178 may be filtered basedon one or more other conditions or parameters indicated in the driverroute data 175, such as particular weather conditions, time of day, typeof vehicle, and/or any other one or more conditions or parameters. Thefiltered subset 180 of the historical driver data 178 may be stored atthe data storage device 132, and/or may be stored at a local memory ofthe controller 151, if desired.

At a block 310, the method 300 may include analyzing the filtered data180 corresponding to the driver route data 175 to determine respectiveweights or weightings 182 of one or more parameters included therein.The parameters may be indicative of, for example, a behavior of theparticular driver while operating the vehicle 108 over the particularroute, a behavior of the vehicle 108 while being operated by theparticular driver along the particular route, or an environmentalcondition of the particular route while the vehicle traversed theparticular route. For example, various parameters may correspond tovarious types of sensors, various types of sensed data, and/or variousenvironmental or contextual conditions, which may include dynamic andstatic conditions occurring along the particular route.

A respective weighting of a particular parameter may be indicative of arelative contribution of the particular parameter towards safer drivingbehavior. For example, the weighting of a parameter indicative ofwhether or not ice is present on the particular route may be greaterthan the weighting of a parameter indicative of the speed limit alongthe particular route, thus indicating that the presence of ice has agreater effect on driving safety than the speed limit. In someimplementations, a respective weighting may additionally oralternatively be indicative of a conditionality of the relativecontribution of the particular parameter towards driving safety based onother parameters and/or values thereof. For example, a parameterindicative of radio volume may have a greater contribution to drivingsafety when the particular route is congested (as indicated by the valueof another parameter) and/or is being utilized by numerous pedestrians(as indicated by the value of still another parameter), whereas theparameter indicative of radio volume may have a lesser contribution todriving safety when the particular route is devoid of other trafficand/or pedestrians.

In an embodiment, the analysis of the filtered historical driver data180 at the block 310 may include performing one or more statistical orlearning analyses or techniques on the filtered data 180. For example, aregression analysis, a cluster analysis, a classification analysis,and/or one or more other types of statistical and/or learning analysesmay be performed on the filtered data 180. A result or output of theapplication of the statistical and/or learning techniques to thefiltered data 180 may include the relative weights or weightings 182 ofone or more parameters included in the filtered data 180. In anexemplary but non-limiting implementation, the one or more statisticalanalyses and/or learning techniques may be applied to the filtered data180 to generate or create a safe driver model 185, which may be, forexample, a statistical model. The safe driver model 185 may indicate ordefine the various weights or weightings 182 of various parametersincluded in the filtered historical driver data 180. As such, theanalysis or analyses of the filtered data 180 at the block 310 maycreate a baseline set of safe driving behaviors for the particular routebased on statistical analyses/learning techniques applied to amultiplicity of driver route data 175 for similar environmental andcontextual conditions along the particular route. Further, at the block310, the analysis or analyses of the filtered data 180 may determinedifferent thresholds of various parameter values that correspond todifferent levels of driving safety. Still further, in some embodiments,different sets of weights 182 and/or different models 185 may begenerated for different portions of the route and/or based on one ormore other parameters. For example, different models 185 may berespectively generated for rush-hour and non-rush-hour time periods,and/or different models 185 may be respectively generated for cars andtrucks. The generated set(s) of weights 182 and/or the generatedmodel(s) 185 may be stored at the data storage device 132 and/or locallyin a memory of the controller 151.

Other techniques may be additionally or alternatively utilized toanalyze the filtered historical driver data 180. For example, the block310 may access a list of prioritizations amongst various parameters(which may or may not include conditional prioritizations), and mayfilter or otherwise utilize the list based on the parameters and/ortheir respective values included in the filtered historical driver data180 to determine the relative weights or weightings 182 amongstparameters that are represented therein. Generally speaking, though, theblock 310 may utilize any desired technique or techniques to determinethe relative weights or weightings 182 amongst the plurality ofparameters included in the filtered historical driver data 180, and therelative weights or weightings 182 may be stored, e.g., at the datastorage device 132 and/or locally in a memory of the controller 151.

At a block 312, the method 300 may include comparing the driver routedata 175 to the results of the analysis performed at the block 310. Inan embodiment, values of parameters included in the driver route data175 may be compared in view of the relative weightings 182 of theparameters as determined at the block 310. At a block 315, the method300 may include determining a level of safety performance of the driver,e.g., for the particular route over the particular interval of time,based on the comparison performed at the block 312. As such, based onthe values of the parameters included in the driver route data 175 andthe relative weightings 182 of various parameters and their respectiveimpacts on driving safety, a safety performance level or score may bedetermined for the driver of the vehicle 108, e.g., over the particularroute in particular interval of time.

In an embodiment of the method 300 in which a safe driver model 185 isgenerated, the blocks 312 and 315 may be executed by utilizing the safedriver model 185. For example, one or more parameter values included inthe driver route data 175 may be input into or provided to the model185. That is, the safe driver model 185 may be applied to one or moreparameter values included in the driver route data 175. Subsequently,based on the application of the model 185 to the one or more parametervalues included in the driver route data 175, the safe driver model 185may generate an indication of the level of performance of the driver,which may be based on the set of weights 182 defined by or included inthe model 185. That is, an output provided by the safe driver model 185may be indicative of a level of safety (e.g., a safety score) of thedriver while he or she was operating the vehicle 108 over the particularroute during the particular time interval.

At a block 318, the method 300 may include transmitting or providing anindication of or corresponding to the determined level of driverperformance to at least one of the vehicle 108, a user interface, oranother computing device or system. The transmitted indication may be,for example, an alert, warning, or notification to the driver of thevehicle 108 and/or to drivers of vehicles 115 a-115 n that are operatingin the vicinity of the vehicle 108. An indication of the alert, warning,or notification may be presented on a user interface disposed at thereceiving vehicle 108, 115 a-115 n, e.g., at an on-board user interfaceof the receiving vehicle, and/or at a user interface of an on-boardmobile device 112. The indication may include one or more suggestedactions that may be performed at the receiving vehicle to mitigateeffects of the determined driver performance, in some scenarios.

In some embodiments, the transmitted indication corresponding to thedetermined level of driver performance may include an instruction thatis to be executed by a computing device on-board the receiving vehicle108, 115 a-115 n to automatically modify an operation of the receivingvehicle 108, 115 a-115 n. For example, if the receiving vehicle isoperating in a fully or partially autonomous mode, and/or if a driver ofthe receiving vehicle has indicated that or given permission for atleast certain modifications to vehicle operations may be automaticallyperformed, the transmitted indication may automatically cause a changeor modification in one or more operating behaviors of the receivingvehicle 108, 112 a-112 n, such as a decrease in rate of speed, a changein steering, etc.

In some embodiments, the transmitted indication corresponding to thedetermined level of driver performance may be received by anothercomputing system that is not disposed at any vehicle. For example, thetransmitted indication may be received by a computing system thatautomatically controls aspects of the infrastructure, e.g., by changingstop light colors at an intersection, providing dynamic warningsdisplayed on highway signs, etc., and such a computing system may sendone or more commands to control the behavior of various infrastructurecomponents (e.g., lights, warning signals, etc.) based on the contentsof the transmitted indication.

In some embodiments, the transmitted indication may be provided toanother computing system for processing. For example, the transmittedindication of the driver's performance may be transmitted to a computingsystem of an insurance company, and the determined driver's performancemay be utilized to determine and/or modify an amount of risk associatedwith the driver, which may in turn be utilized to determine an amount ofan insurance premium, the amount of a deductible, and/or the creationand/or modification of these and/or other financial terms associatedwith obtaining or maintaining an insurance policy for the driver and/orfor the vehicle 108.

In an embodiment, at least a portion (and in some cases, all) of themethod 300 may be executed in real-time. That is, while a driver istraversing a particular route, the method 300 may determine the driver'son-going, current, or real-time performance while operating the vehicleon that particular route and provide suggestions to the driver (e.g.,via a user interface disposed at the vehicle) for one or more drivingmodifications while he or she is operating the vehicle over theparticular route (e.g., slow down to a certain speed, turn on yourheadlights, etc.). Additionally or alternatively, based on the driver'son-going or real-time performance, the method 300 may provide one ormore instructions to the vehicle to automatically modify an operatingbehavior of the vehicle while the driver is operating the vehicle overthe particular route. For example, if the driver has opted-in, givenpermission for, or otherwise assented to various automatic vehicleoperations, based on the determination of the driver's performance, themethod 300 may include instructing the vehicle to automatically changesome aspect of its operation while traversing the particular route,e.g., automatically turn on traction control, automatically turn downthe radio volume, etc.

In some embodiments (not shown), the method 300 may include updating thehistorical driver data (e.g., by adding the obtained driver route dataof the block 302 and/or other driver route data), and subsequentlyanalyzing the updated historical driver data (e.g., at the block 310) todetermine updated weightings of parameters and/or updated thresholds.The updated weights of the parameters and/or the updated thresholds maybe utilized to assess the subject driver's safety performance, forexample. In some embodiments, updating the historical driver data,updating the weightings of the parameters and/or thresholds, anddetermining the subject driver's current safety performance accordinglymay be done in real-time or near-real-time. For example, while thedriver is operating the vehicle 108 over the particular route, aninitial assessment or evaluation of the driver's safety performance maybe determined by the method 300 for a first portion of the particularroute. Subsequently, the weights of the parameters and/or the thresholdsmay be updated by the method 300 based on newly obtained historicaldriver data while the driver continues to operate the vehicle over theparticular route, and an updated assessment/evaluation of the driver'ssafety performance for a second portion of the particular route may bedetermined by the method 300 based on the updated parameter weightsand/or thresholds. As such, the weights of the parameters and/orthresholds may be dynamically adjusted, e.g., in an up-to-the-minutemanner or in real-time based on driver data of one or more other driversthat is obtained in real-time. For example, the safe-driver model 185may be dynamically updated or adjusted in real-time. As such, thesubject driver's safety performance may be assessed in real-time usingthe dynamically adjusted weights, thresholds, and/or model. Thus, a moretimely, granulated, and accurate assessment of the driver's safetyperformance is able to be provided by the method 300 as compared withknown techniques.

FIG. 4 depicts a flow diagram of an exemplary method 400 for determininga vehicle driver's performance. At least a portion of the method 400 maybe performed by the system 100, for example, by the on-board computer110, the on-board mobile device 112, and/or the remote computing system130. In some embodiments, at least a portion of the method 400 may beperformed in conjunction with one or more portions of the method 300.For ease of discussion, and not for limitation purposes, the method 400is discussed with simultaneous reference to the system 100, although itis understood that the method 400 may operate in conjunction with othersystems and/or computing devices.

At a block 402, the method 400 may include collecting historical driverdata 178 that includes data indicative of driving behavior, vehicleoperations and behavior, and/or environmental conditions and contexts.The historical driver data 178 may have obtained for multiple drivers ofmultiple vehicles along multiple routes and over multiple periods oftime, for example. In an embodiment, the historical driver data 178 mayinclude respective driver route data 175 of a plurality of drivers of aplurality of vehicles, over a plurality of routes and over a pluralityof different periods of time or different time intervals. At least someof the historical driver data 178 may have been generated by and/orcollected from multiple sets of sensors associated with the vehicles108, 115 a-115 n (e.g., on-board sensors 118, off-board sensors 150,etc.). At least some of the historical driver data 178 may includethird-party data which may have been generated and provided by one ormore third-party data providers. Typically, third-party data includesdata that is indicative of one or more environmental or contextualconditions occurring along various routes over various intervals oftime. Third-party data may include, for example, data from weatherdatabases, road construction databases, traffic congestion databases,road network databases, IoT (Internet-of-Things) or sensor databasesimplemented by a city or other jurisdiction, etc. Third-party data maybe stored in databases maintained by third parties (e.g., a party orentity other than that providing the system 100), and the third-partydata may be provided to the system 100, e.g., as a data feed via thenetwork 120. In an embodiment, each data point included in thehistorical driver data 178, whether sensed or obtained via athird-party, may have a respective timestamp and indication of arespective geo-location associated therewith, which may be indicative ofthe time and geo-location at which the respective data point wascollected or obtained. As such, at least a portion of the historicaldriver data 178 may be time-series data. The collected historical driverdata 178 may be stored in the data storage device 132, for example.

At a block 405, the method 400 may include analyzing the historicaldriver data 178 to determine respective weights or weightings 182 of oneor more parameters included therein. The parameters may be indicativeof, for example, behaviors of drivers while operating vehicles overvarious routes at various times, behaviors of vehicles will beingoperated by drivers along the various routes at various times, orenvironmental or contextual conditions occurring over the various routesat the various times. For example, various parameters may correspond todata collected by various types of sensors, various types of senseddata, and/or various environmental or contextual conditions, which mayinclude both static and dynamically occurring conditions.

A respective weight or weighting of a particular parameter may beindicative of a relative contribution of the particular parametertowards safer driving behavior. For example, the weighting of aparameter indicative of whether or not ice is present on the particularroute may be greater than the weighting of a parameter indicative of thespeed limit along the particular route, thus indicating that thepresence of ice has a greater effect on driving safety than the speedlimit. In some implementations, a respective weighting may additionallyor alternatively be indicative of a conditionality of the relativecontribution of the particular parameter towards driving safety based onother parameters and/or values thereof. For example, a parameterindicative of radio volume may have a greater contribution to drivingsafety (and therefore a greater weight value) when the particular routeis congested (as indicated by the value of another parameter) and/or isbeing utilized by numerous pedestrians (as indicated by the value ofstill another parameter), whereas the parameter indicative of radiovolume may have a lesser contribution to driving safety (and therefore alesser weight value) when the particular route is devoid of othertraffic and/or pedestrians.

In an embodiment, analyzing the historical driver data 178 at the block405 may include performing one or more statistical or learning analysesor techniques on the historical driver data 178. For example, aregression analysis, a cluster analysis, a classification analysis,and/or one or more other types of statistical and/or learning analysesmay be performed on the historical driver data 178. A result or outputof the application of the statistical and/or learning techniques to thehistorical driver data 178 may include the relative weights orweightings 182 of one or more parameters included in the historicaldriver data 178. In an exemplary but non-limiting implementation, theone or more statistical analyses and/or learning techniques may beapplied to the historical driver data 178 to generate or create a safedriver model 185, which may be, for example, a statistical model. Thesafe driver model 185 may indicate or define the various weights orweightings 182 of various parameters included in the historical driverdata 178. As such, the analysis or analyses of the historical driverdata 170 at the block 405 may create a baseline set of safe drivingbehaviors for a particular route based on statistical analyses/learningtechniques applied to a multiplicity of driver route data 175 forsimilar environmental and contextual conditions along the particularroute. Further, at the block 405, the analysis or analyses of thehistorical driver data 178 may determine different thresholds of variousparameter values that correspond to different levels of driving safety.Still further, in some embodiments, different sets of weights 182 and/ordifferent models 185 may be generated for different routes or portionsthereof. The generated set(s) of weights 182 and/or the generatedmodel(s) 185 may be stored at the data storage device 132 and/or locallyin a memory of the controller 151.

Other techniques may be additionally or alternatively utilized toanalyze the historical driver data 178. For example, the block 405 mayaccess a list of prioritizations amongst various parameters (which mayor may not include conditional prioritizations), and may filter orotherwise utilize the list based on the parameters and/or theirrespective values included in the historical driver data 178 todetermine the relative weights or weightings 182 amongst parameters thatare represented therein.

Generally speaking, though, the analysis or analyses performed at block405 may utilize any desired technique or techniques to determine therelative weights or weightings 182 amongst the plurality of parametersincluded in the historical driver data 178. The analysis or analysesperformed at the block 405 may be positively or negatively oriented, asdesired. For example, the analyses performed at the block 405 maydetermine particular parameter values and/or combinations thereofindicative of safe driving behavior (and optionally, thresholdscorresponding to different levels of safe driving behavior), and/or theanalyses may determine particular parameter values and/or combinationsthereof that are indicative of unsafe driving behavior (and optionally,thresholds corresponding to different levels of unsafe drivingbehavior). In some embodiments, different sets of weights 182 may begenerated for different routes or portions thereof. In some embodiments,different sets of weights 182 may be generated for differentenvironmental conditions. For example, different sets of weights 182 maybe generated for rush hour and for non-rush hour traffic, and/ordifferent sets of weights 182 may be generated for different roadconditions. The generated set(s) of weights or weightings 182 may bestored, e.g., at the data storage device 132 and/or locally in a memoryof the controller 151.

At a block 408, the method 400 may include collecting driver route data(e.g., driver route data 175) that is associated with a vehicle (e.g.,the vehicle 108) for a particular route over a particular interval oftime. Generally speaking, the driver route data 175 may include datathat is indicative of a behavior of the vehicle 108, a behavior of thedriver of the vehicle 108, and/or various contextual and environmentalconditions occurring while the vehicle is operated or is operating alongthe particular route over the particular time interval. The driver routedata 175 may include data collected from one or more sensors that aredisposed on-board the vehicle 108 (e.g., the on-board sensors 118), datacollected from one or more sensors that are disposed off-board thevehicle 108 (e.g., the off-board sensors 150), and/or third-partygenerated data that is indicative of environmental and/or contextualconditions occurring along the particular route during the particulartime period or interval. Third-party data may include, for example, datathat is stored in databases maintained by third parties, e.g., weatherdatabases, road construction databases, traffic congestion databases,road network databases, IoT (Internet-of-Things) or sensor databasesimplemented by a city or other jurisdiction, etc., and that is providedvia a data feed to the system 100, e.g., via the network 120. Some orall of the data points included in the driver route data 175 may includerespective indications of a time and a geo-location at which the datapoint was collected or observed. That is, at least some of the driverroute data 175 may be time-series data.

At a block 410, the method 300 may include comparing the driver routedata 175 collected at the block 408 to the results of the analysis ofthe historical driver data 178 performed at the block 405 to determinethe driver's level of performance for the particular route over theparticular time interval. In an embodiment, values of one or moreparameters included in the driver route data 175 may be compared in viewof relative weightings 182 of the parameters as determined at the block405. The block 410 may include determining a level of safety performanceof the driver, e.g., for the particular route over the particularinterval of time. As such, based on the values of the parametersincluded in the driver route data 175 and the relative weightings 182 ofvarious parameters and their respective impacts on driving safety, asafety performance level or score may be determined for the driver ofthe vehicle 108, e.g., over the particular route in particular intervalof time.

In an embodiment of the method 400 in which a safe driver model 185 isgenerated, the block 410 may be executed by utilizing the safe drivermodel 185. For example, one or more parameter values included in thedriver route data 175 may be input into or provided to the model 185.That is, the safe driver model 185 may be applied to one or moreparameter values included in the driver route data 175. Subsequently,based on the application of the model 185 to the one or more parametervalues included in the driver route data 175, the safe driver model 185may generate an indication of the level of performance of the driver,which may be based on the set of weights 182 defined by or included inthe model 185. That is, an output provided by the safe driver model 185may be indicative of a level of safety (e.g., a safety score) of thedriver while he or she was operating the vehicle 108 over the particularroute during the particular time interval.

At a block 412, the method 400 may include transmitting or providing anindication of or corresponding to the determined level of driverperformance to at least one of the vehicle 108, a user interface, oranother computing device or system. The transmitted indication may be,for example, an alert, warning, or notification to the driver of thevehicle 108, to drivers of nearby vehicles 115 a-115 n, and/or toautonomous vehicles 115 a-115 n that are operating in the vicinity ofthe vehicle 108. An indication of the alert, warning, or notificationmay be presented on a user interface disposed at the receiving vehicle108, 115 a-115 n, e.g., at an on-board user interface of the receivingvehicle, and/or at a user interface of an on-board mobile device 112.The indication may include one or more suggested actions that may beperformed at the receiving vehicle to mitigate effects of the determineddriver performance, in some scenarios.

In some embodiments, the transmitted indication corresponding to thedetermined level of driver performance may include an instruction thatis to be executed by a computing device on-board the receiving vehicle108, 115 a-115 n to automatically modify an operation of the receivingvehicle 108, 115 a-115 n. For example, if the receiving vehicle isoperating in a fully or partially autonomous mode, and/or if a driver ofthe receiving vehicle has indicated that at least certain modificationsto vehicle operations may be automatically performed, the transmittedindication may automatically cause a change or modification in one ormore operating behaviors of the receiving vehicle 108, 115 a-115 n, suchas a decrease in rate of speed, a change in steering, etc.

In some embodiments, the transmitted indication corresponding to thedetermined level of driver performance may be received by anothercomputing system that is not disposed at any vehicle. For example, thetransmitted indication may be received by a computing system thatautomatically controls aspects of the infrastructure, e.g., by changingstop light colors at an intersection, providing dynamic warningsdisplayed on highway signs, etc., and such a computing system may sendone or more commands to control the behavior of various infrastructurecomponents (e.g., lights, warning signals, etc.) based on the contentsof the transmitted indication.

In some embodiments, the transmitted indication may be provided toanother computing system for processing and/or use in otherapplications. For example, the transmitted indication of the driver'sperformance may be transmitted to a computing system of an insurancecompany, and the determined driver's performance may be utilized todetermine and/or modify an amount of risk associated with the driver,which may in turn be utilized to determine an amount of an insurancepremium, the amount of a deductible, and/or the creation and/ormodification of these and/or other financial terms associated withobtaining or maintaining an insurance policy for the driver and/or forthe vehicle 108.

It is noted that in some embodiments, some or all of the method 400 maybe executed in real-time. That is, while a driver is traversing aparticular route, the method 400 may execute to determine the driver'son-going, current, or real-time performance on that particular route andprovide suggestions to the driver (e.g., via a user interface disposedat the vehicle) for one or more driving modifications while he or she isoperating the vehicle over the particular route (e.g., slow down to acertain speed, turn on your headlights, etc.). Additionally oralternatively, based on the driver's on-going or real-time performance,the method 400 may execute to provide one or more instructions to thevehicle while the driver is operating the vehicle over the particularroute. For example, if the driver has opted-in, given permission for, orassented to various automatic vehicle operations, based on thedetermination of the driver's performance, the method 400 may includeinstructing the vehicle to automatically change some aspect of itsoperation while traversing the particular route, e.g., automaticallyturn on traction control, automatically turn down the radio volume, etc.

In some embodiments (not shown), the method 400 may include updating thehistorical driver data (e.g., by adding the obtained driver route dataof the block 408 and/or other driver route data), and subsequentlyanalyzing the updated historical driver data (e.g., at the block 405) todetermine updated weightings of parameters and/or updated thresholds.The updated weights of the parameters and/or the updated thresholds maybe utilized to assess the subject driver's safety performance and/orother drivers' respective safety performances, for example. In someembodiments, updating the historical driver data, updating theweightings of the parameters and/or thresholds, and determining adriver's current safety performance accordingly may be done in real-timeor near-real-time. For example, while the driver is operating thevehicle 108 over a particular route, an initial assessment or evaluationof the driver's safety performance may be determined by the method 400for a first portion of the particular route. Subsequently, the weightsof the parameters and/or the thresholds may be updated by the method 400based on newly obtained historical driver data while the drivercontinues to operate the vehicle over the particular route, and anupdated assessment/evaluation of the driver's safety performance for asecond portion of the particular route may be determined by the method400 based on the updated parameter weights and/or thresholds. In thismanner, the weights of the parameters and/or thresholds may bedynamically adjusted, e.g., in an up-to-the-minute or real-time mannerbased on driver data of one or more other drivers that is obtained inreal-time. For example, the safe-driver model 185 may be dynamicallyupdated or adjusted in real-time. Accordingly, the subject driver'ssafety performance and other drivers' safety performances may beassessed in real-time using the dynamically adjusted weights,thresholds, and/or model. Thus, a more timely, granulated, and accurateassessment of the drivers' safety performances is able to be provided bythe method 400 as compared with known techniques for assessing driverperformance.

In some aspects of the systems, methods, and techniques describedherein, the driver may opt-in to a rewards, loyalty, discount, or otherprogram. For example, the driver may allow the remote computing system130 to collect sensor, telematics, vehicle, mobile device, driverperformance, and other types of data discussed herein. With customerpermission or affirmative consent, the data collected may be analyzed(whether by the remote computing system 130 or by another computingsystem that is communicatively connected to the remote computing system130) to provide certain benefits to the driver. For instance, insurancecost savings may be provided to the driver based on his or hercontextual driving performance. Recommendations that lower risk orprovide cost savings to the driver may also be generated and provided tocustomers based upon data analysis.

Although the text herein sets forth a detailed description of numerousdifferent embodiments, it should be understood that the legal scope ofthe invention is defined by the words of the claims set forth at the endof this patent. The detailed description is to be construed as exemplaryonly and does not describe every possible embodiment, as describingevery possible embodiment would be impractical, if not impossible. Onecould implement numerous alternate embodiments, using either currenttechnology or technology developed after the filing date of this patent,which would still fall within the scope of the claims.

It should also be understood that, unless a term is expressly defined inthis patent using the sentence “As used herein, the term ‘______’ ishereby defined to mean . . . ” or a similar sentence, there is no intentto limit the meaning of that term, either expressly or by implication,beyond its plain or ordinary meaning, and such term should not beinterpreted to be limited in scope based upon any statement made in anysection of this patent (other than the language of the claims). To theextent that any term recited in the claims at the end of this disclosureis referred to in this disclosure in a manner consistent with a singlemeaning, that is done for sake of clarity only so as to not confuse thereader, and it is not intended that such claim term be limited, byimplication or otherwise, to that single meaning. Finally, the patentclaims at the end of this patent application are not intended to beconstrued under 35 U.S.C. § 112(f) unless traditionalmeans-plus-function language is expressly recited, such as “means for”or “step for” language being explicitly recited in the claim(s). Thesystems and methods described herein are directed to an improvement tocomputer functionality, and improve the functioning of conventionalcomputers.

Throughout this specification, plural instances may implementcomponents, operations, or structures described as a single instance.Although individual operations of one or more methods are illustratedand described as separate operations, one or more of the individualoperations may be performed concurrently, and nothing requires that theoperations be performed in the order illustrated. Structures andfunctionality presented as separate components in example configurationsmay be implemented as a combined structure or component. Similarly,structures and functionality presented as a single component may beimplemented as separate components. These and other variations,modifications, additions, and improvements fall within the scope of thesubject matter herein.

Additionally, certain embodiments are described herein as includinglogic or a number of routines, subroutines, applications, orinstructions. These may constitute either software (code embodied on anon-transitory, tangible machine-readable medium) or hardware. Inhardware, the routines, etc., are tangible units capable of performingcertain operations and may be configured or arranged in a certainmanner. In example embodiments, one or more computer systems (e.g., astandalone, client or server computer system) or one or more modules ofa computer system (e.g., a processor or a group of processors) may beconfigured by software (e.g., an application or application portion) asa module that operates to perform certain operations as describedherein.

In various embodiments, a module may be implemented mechanically orelectronically. Accordingly, the term “module” should be understood toencompass a tangible entity, be that an entity that is physicallyconstructed, permanently configured (e.g., hardwired), or temporarilyconfigured (e.g., programmed) to operate in a certain manner or toperform certain operations described herein. Considering embodiments inwhich modules are temporarily configured (e.g., programmed), each of themodules need not be configured or instantiated at any one instance intime. For example, where the modules comprise a general-purposeprocessor configured using software, the general-purpose processor maybe configured as respective different modules at different times.Software may accordingly configure a processor, for example, toconstitute a particular module at one instance of time and to constitutea different module at a different instance of time.

Modules can provide information to, and receive information from, othermodules. Accordingly, the described modules may be regarded as beingcommunicatively coupled. Where multiple of such modules existcontemporaneously, communications may be achieved through signaltransmission (e.g., over appropriate circuits and buses) that connectthe modules. In embodiments in which multiple modules are configured orinstantiated at different times, communications between such modules maybe achieved, for example, through the storage and retrieval ofinformation in memory structures to which the multiple modules haveaccess. For example, one module may perform an operation and store theoutput of that operation in a memory device to which it iscommunicatively coupled. A further module may then, at a later time,access the memory device to retrieve and process the stored output.Modules may also initiate communications with input or output devices,and can operate on a resource (e.g., a collection of information).

The various operations of example methods described herein may beperformed, at least partially, by one or more processors that aretemporarily configured (e.g., by software) or permanently configured toperform the relevant operations. Whether temporarily or permanentlyconfigured, such processors may constitute processor-implemented modulesthat operate to perform one or more operations or functions. The modulesreferred to herein may, in some example embodiments, compriseprocessor-implemented modules. Moreover, the systems and methodsdescribed herein are directed to an improvement to computerfunctionality and improve the functioning of conventional computers.

Similarly, the methods or routines described herein may be at leastpartially processor-implemented. For example, at least some of theoperations of a method may be performed by one or more processors orprocessor-implemented modules. The performance of certain of theoperations may be distributed among the one or more processors, not onlyresiding within a single machine, but deployed across a number ofmachines. In some example embodiments, the processor or processors maybe located in a single location (e.g., within a home environment, anoffice environment or as a server farm), while in other embodiments theprocessors may be distributed across a number of locations.

The performance of certain of the operations may be distributed amongthe one or more processors, not only residing within a single machine,but deployed across a number of machines. In some example embodiments,the one or more processors or processor-implemented modules may belocated in a single geographic location (e.g., within a homeenvironment, an office environment, or a server farm). In other exampleembodiments, the one or more processors or processor-implemented modulesmay be distributed across a number of geographic locations.

Unless specifically stated otherwise, discussions herein using wordssuch as “processing,” “computing,” “calculating,” “determining,”“presenting,” “displaying,” or the like may refer to actions orprocesses of a machine (e.g., a computer) that manipulates or transformsdata represented as physical (e.g., electronic, magnetic, or optical)quantities within one or more memories (e.g., volatile memory,non-volatile memory, or a combination thereof), registers, or othermachine components that receive, store, transmit, or displayinformation. Some embodiments may be described using the expression“coupled” and “connected” along with their derivatives. For example,some embodiments may be described using the term “coupled” to indicatethat two or more elements are in direct physical or electrical contact.The term “coupled,” however, may also mean that two or more elements arenot in direct contact with each other, but yet still co-operate orinteract with each other. The embodiments are not limited in thiscontext.

As used herein any reference to “one embodiment” or “an embodiment”means that a particular element, feature, structure, or characteristicdescribed in connection with the embodiment may be included in at leastone embodiment. The appearances of the phrase “in one embodiment” invarious places in the specification are not necessarily all referring tothe same embodiment. In addition, use of the “a” or “an” are employed todescribe elements and components of the embodiments herein. This is donemerely for convenience and to give a general sense of the description.This description, and the claims that follow, should be read to includeone or at least one and the singular also includes the plural unless itis obvious that it is meant otherwise.

As used herein, the terms “comprises,” “comprising,” “includes,”“including,” “has,” “having” or any other variation thereof, areintended to cover a non-exclusive inclusion. For example, a process,method, article, or apparatus that comprises a list of elements is notnecessarily limited to only those elements but may include otherelements not expressly listed or inherent to such process, method,article, or apparatus. Further, unless expressly stated to the contrary,“or” refers to an inclusive or and not to an exclusive or. For example,a condition A or B is satisfied by any one of the following: A is true(or present) and B is false (or not present), A is false (or notpresent) and B is true (or present), and both A and B are true (orpresent).

This detailed description is to be construed as exemplary only and doesnot describe every possible embodiment, as describing every possibleembodiment would be impractical, if not impossible. One could implementnumerous alternate embodiments, using either current technology ortechnology developed after the filing date of this application. Uponreading this disclosure, those of skill in the art will appreciate stilladditional alternative structural and functional designs for system anda method for assigning mobile device data to a vehicle through thedisclosed principles herein. Thus, while particular embodiments andapplications have been illustrated and described, it is to be understoodthat the disclosed embodiments are not limited to the preciseconstruction and components disclosed herein. Various modifications,changes and variations, which will be apparent to those skilled in theart, may be made in the arrangement, operation and details of the methodand apparatus disclosed herein without departing from the spirit andscope defined in the appended claims.

The particular features, structures, or characteristics of any specificembodiment may be combined in any suitable manner and in any suitablecombination with one or more other embodiments, including the use ofselected features without corresponding use of other features. Inaddition, many modifications may be made to adapt a particularapplication, situation or material to the essential scope and spirit ofthe present invention. It is to be understood that other variations andmodifications of the embodiments of the present invention described andillustrated herein are possible in light of the teachings herein and areto be considered part of the spirit and scope of the present invention.

While the preferred embodiments of the invention have been described, itshould be understood that the invention is not so limited andmodifications may be made without departing from the invention. Thescope of the invention is defined by the appended claims, and alldevices that come within the meaning of the claims, either literally orby equivalence, are intended to be embraced therein. It is thereforeintended that the foregoing detailed description be regarded asillustrative rather than limiting, and that it be understood that it isthe following claims, including all equivalents, that are intended todefine the spirit and scope of this invention.

What is claimed:
 1. A system for determining driver performance, thesystem comprising: a processor; and memory in communication with theprocessor, the memory storing instructions that, when executed by theprocessor, cause the processor to perform operations including: causinga vehicle sensor to capture first data, wherein the first data iscaptured while the vehicle is operated by a first driver to traverse aroute; accessing second data exclusive of the first data, the seconddata indicating: dynamic contextual attributes of the route, andhistorical driving behaviors of a second driver distinct from the firstdriver; determining a safe driving threshold based at least in part onthe dynamic contextual attributes and the historical driving behaviors;determining that a parameter represented in the first data meets orexceeds the safe driving threshold; based at least in part ondetermining that the parameter meets or exceeds the safe drivingthreshold, generating an operating instruction; and transmitting theoperating instruction to a processor of the vehicle, the operatinginstruction causing the processor of the vehicle to modify anoperational behavior of the vehicle such that the parameter is below thesafe driving threshold as the vehicle traverses the route.
 2. The systemof claim 1, wherein the vehicle sensor is fixedly attached to thevehicle or comprises a component of a mobile electronic device disposedin the vehicle.
 3. The system of claim 1, wherein the second dataincludes a second parameter indicating a driving behavior associatedwith the second driver and a third parameter indicating an operatingbehavior associated with a second vehicle operated by the second driver.4. The system of claim 1, wherein the operations further comprise:determining that the safe driving threshold differs from a predetermineddriving threshold, the predetermined driving threshold corresponding tothe route and being established independent of the first data; andgenerating the operating instruction is further based at least in parton determining that the safe driving threshold differs from thepredetermined driving threshold.
 5. The system of claim 4, whereincausing the processor to modify the operational behavior of the vehiclecomprises causing the processor to modify the operational behavior suchthat the vehicle operates within the safe driving threshold and outsideof the predetermined driving threshold.
 6. The system of claim 1,wherein the first data further includes data captured by anenvironmental sensor fixedly disposed in an environment along the route.7. The system of claim 1, wherein the first data further includes datacaptured by a second vehicle sensor fixedly attached to a second vehiclein an environment, wherein the second vehicle is distinct from thevehicle.
 8. The system of claim 1, wherein the dynamic contextualattributes of the route comprise at least one of weather, roadcongestion, an environmental condition of the route, or traffic alongthe route.
 9. The system of claim 1, wherein the vehicle sensorcomprises at least one of a camera, an optical sensor, a speed sensor, aweight sensor, a noise sensor, a heat sensor, an accelerometer, alocation tracking sensor, a proximity sensor, a seat belt sensor, or asensor to detect an operation of an instrument included in the vehicle.10. A method comprising: causing a vehicle sensor to capture first data,wherein the first data is captured while the vehicle is operated by afirst driver to traverse a route; accessing second data exclusive of thefirst data, the second data indicating dynamic contextual attributes ofthe route and historical driving behaviors of a second driver distinctfrom the first driver; determining a safe driving threshold based atleast in part on the dynamic contextual attributes and the historicaldriving behaviors; determining that a parameter represented in the firstdata meets or exceeds the safe driving threshold; generating, based atleast in part on determining that the parameter meets or exceeds thesafe driving threshold, an operating instruction; and transmitting theoperating instruction to a processor of the vehicle, the operatinginstruction causing the processor of the vehicle to modify anoperational behavior of the vehicle such that the parameter is below thesafe driving threshold as the vehicle traverses the route.
 11. Themethod of claim 10, determining the safe driving threshold is furtherbased at least in part on a weight value generated by a model andassociated with the parameter.
 12. The method of claim 10, furthercomprising: determining that the safe driving threshold differs from apredetermined driving threshold, the predetermined driving thresholdcorresponding to the route and being established independent of thefirst data; and generating the operating instruction is further based atleast in part on determining that the safe driving threshold differsfrom the predetermined driving threshold.
 13. The method of claim 10,further comprising: generating, based at least in part on determiningthat the parameter meets or exceeds the safe driving threshold, at leastone of an alert or a suggested driving behavior; and transmitting the atleast one of the alert or the suggested driving behavior to the vehiclefor presentation to the driver.
 14. The method of claim 10, wherein thevehicle sensor is one of a sensor fixedly attached to the vehicle or asensor configured at a mobile electronic device disposed in the vehicle.15. The method of claim 14, wherein causing the processor to modify theoperational behavior of the vehicle comprises causing the processor tomodify the operational behavior such that the vehicle operates withinthe safe driving threshold and outside of a predetermined drivingthreshold distinct from the safe driving threshold.
 16. The method ofclaim 10, wherein the vehicle sensor comprises at least one of a camera,an optical sensor, a speed sensor, a weight sensor, a noise sensor, aheat sensor, an accelerometer, a force sensor, a location trackingsensor, a proximity sensor, a seat belt sensor, or a sensor to detect anoperation of an instrument included in the vehicle.
 17. A non-transitorycomputer-readable storage medium storing processor-executableinstructions that, when executed, cause one or more processors to: causea vehicle sensor to capture first data, wherein the first data iscaptured while the vehicle is operated by a first driver to traverse aroute; access second data exclusive of the first data, the second dataindicating dynamic contextual attributes of the route and historicaldriving behaviors of a second driver distinct from the first driver;determine a safe driving threshold based at least in part on the dynamiccontextual attributes and the historical driving behaviors; determinethat a parameter represented in the first data meets or exceeds the safedriving threshold; generate, based at least in part on determining thatthe parameter meets or exceeds the safe driving threshold, an operatinginstruction; and transmit the operating instruction to a processor ofthe vehicle, the operating instruction causing the processor of thevehicle to modify an operational behavior of the vehicle such that theparameter is below the safe driving threshold as the vehicle traversesthe route.
 18. The non-transitory computer-readable storage medium ofclaim 17, further comprising characterizing a driving event occurringalong a portion of the route as being safe based on the safe drivingthreshold, wherein the driving event would have been characterized asunsafe based on a predetermined driving threshold distinct from the safedriving threshold.
 19. The non-transitory computer-readable storagemedium of claim 17, wherein the vehicle sensor comprises at least one ofa camera, an optical sensor, a speed sensor, a weight sensor, a noisesensor, a heat sensor, an accelerometer, a force sensor, a locationtracking sensor, a proximity sensor, a seat belt sensor, or a sensor todetect an operation of an instrument included in the vehicle.
 20. Asystem for determining driver performance, the system comprising: meansfor causing a vehicle sensor to capture first data, wherein the firstdata is captured while the vehicle is operated by a first driver totraverse a route; means for accessing second data exclusive of the firstdata, the second data indicating dynamic contextual attributes of theroute and historical driving behaviors of a second driver distinct fromthe first driver; means for determining a safe driving threshold basedat least in part on the dynamic contextual attributes and the historicaldriving behaviors; means for determining that a parameter represented inthe first data meets or exceeds the safe driving threshold; means forgenerating, based at least in part on determining that the parametermeets or exceeds the safe driving threshold, an operating instruction;and means for transmitting the operating instruction to a processor ofthe vehicle, the operating instruction causing the processor of thevehicle to modify an operational behavior of the vehicle such that theparameter is below the safe driving threshold as the vehicle traversesthe route.